U bent hier

Van dingen die voorbijkomen

Overheidsaanpak milieucriminaliteit niet op orde

Binnenllands Bestuur - 22 juli 2021 - 4:42pm
Gebrekkige handhaving van milieuregels biedt criminelen én bedrijven in Nederland volop gelegenheid om milieudelicten te begaan. De schade die ze daarmee veroorzaken is groot en ‘vermijdbaar’, zo staat te lezen in het Dreigingsbeeld …

Percentage of tenure-stream faculty who are female in PhD programs in philosophy increased about 40-50% since 2004...

Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog - 22 juli 2021 - 4:15pm
...with some variation depending on the caliber of the program: top analytically-oriented departments saw significant increases (18% of tenure-stream faculty were female in 2004, now 26% are), but still do not have as high a percentage of female faculty as... Brian Leiter

The Epic of Gilgamesh, the Oldest-Known Work of Literature in World History

Open Culture - 22 juli 2021 - 4:00pm

You’re probably familiar with The Epic of Gilgamesh, the story of an overbearing Sumerian king and demi-god who meets his match in wild man Enkidu. Gilgamesh is humbled, the two become best friends, kill the forest guardian Humbaba, and face down spurned goddess Ishtar’s Bull of Heaven. When Enkidu dies, Gilgamesh goes looking for the only man to live forever, a survivor of a legendary pre-Biblical flood. The great king then tries, and fails, to gain eternal life himself. The story is packed with episodes of sex and violence, like the modern-day comics that are modeled on ancient mythology. It is also, as you may know, the oldest-known work of literature on Earth, written in cuneiform, the oldest-known form of writing.

This is one version of the story. But Gilgamesh beaks out of the tidy frame usually put around it. It is a “poem that exists in a pile of broken pieces,” Joan Acocella writes at The New Yorker, “in an extremely dead language.”

If Gilgamesh were based on a real king of Ur, he would have lived around 2700 BC. The first stories written about him come from some 800 years after that time, during the Old Babylonian period, after the last of the Sumerian dynasties had already ended. The version we tend to read in world literature and mythology courses comes from several hundred years later, notes the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s Ira Spar:

Some time in the twelfth century B.C., Sin-leqi-unninni, a Babylonian scholar, recorded what was to become a classic version of the Gilgamesh tale. Not content to merely copy an old version of the tale, this scholar most likely assembled various versions of the story from both oral and written sources and updated them in light of the literary concerns of his day, which included questions about human mortality and the nature of wisdom…. Sin-leqi-unninni recast Enkidu as Gilgamesh’s companion and brought to the fore concerns about unbridled heroism, the responsibilities of good governance, and the purpose of life. 

This so-called “Standard Babylonian Version,” as you’ll learn in the TED-Ed video at the top by Soraya Field Fiorio, was itself only discovered in 1849 — very recent by comparison with other ancient texts we regularly read and study. The first archaeologists to discover it were searching not for Sumerian literature but for evidence that proved the Biblical stories. They thought they’d found it in Nineveh, in the excavated library of King Ashurbanipal, the oldest library in the world. Instead, they discovered the broken, incomplete tablets containing the story of Gilgamesh and Utnapishtim, who, like Noah from the Hebrew Bible, built an enormous boat in advance of a divinely ordered flood. The first person to translate the passages was so excited, he stripped off his clothes.

The flood story wasn’t the knock-down proof Christian scholars hoped for, but the discovery of the Gilgamesh epic was even more important for our understanding of the ancient world. What we know of the story, however, was already edited and redacted to suit a millennia-old agenda. The Epic of Gilgamesh “explains that Gilgamesh, although he is king of Uruk, acts as an arrogant, impulsive, and irresponsible ruler,” Spar writes. “Only after a frustrating and vain attempt to find eternal life does he emerge from immaturity to realize that one’s achievements, rather than immortality, serve as an enduring legacy.”

Other, much older versions of his story show the mythical king and his exploits in a different light. So how should we read Gilgamesh in the 21st century, a few thousand years after his first stories were composed? You can begin here with the TED-Ed summary and Crash Course in World Mythology video further up. Dig much deeper with the lecture above from Andrew George, Professor of Babylonian at the University of London’s School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS).

George has produced one of the most highly respected translations of Gilgamesh, Acocella writes, one that “gives what remains of Sin-leqi-unninni’s text” and appends other fragmentary tablets discovered in Baghdad, showing how the meaning of the cuneiform symbols changed over the course of the millennia between the Old Babylonian stories and the “New Babylonian Version” of the Epic of Gilgamesh we think we know. Hear a full reading of Gilgamesh above, as translated by N.K. Sanders.

Related Content: 

Hear The Epic of Gilgamesh Read in its Original Ancient Language, Akkadian

20 New Lines from The Epic of Gilgamesh Discovered in Iraq, Adding New Details to the Story

World Literature in 13 Parts: From Gilgamesh to García Márquez

Josh Jones is a writer and musician based in Durham, NC. Follow him at @jdmagness

The Epic of Gilgamesh, the Oldest-Known Work of Literature in World History is a post from: Open Culture. Follow us on Facebook and Twitter, or get our Daily Email. And don't miss our big collections of Free Online Courses, Free Online Movies, Free eBooksFree Audio Books, Free Foreign Language Lessons, and MOOCs.

Farewell Delta variant, hello Gamma variant

Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog - 22 juli 2021 - 3:44pm
The Gamma variant of the coronavirus--responsible for the devastating second outbreak of COVID in Manaus, Brazil earlier this year--is already four times more common than Delta in, for example, Illinois. And while initial evidence is that the RNA-based Pfizer vaccine... Brian Leiter

Aardbevingen zijn nauwelijks reden voor verkoop woning

Binnenllands Bestuur - 22 juli 2021 - 3:42pm
Huiseigenaren in het Groningse aardbevingsgebied verkopen hun woning nauwelijks vanwege de aardbevingen of de schade daarvan aan de woning. Andere redenen, zoals groter of kleiner willen wonen, leeftijd en gezondheid blijken een veel grotere rol te …

Digit Debates

OII - Videos - 22 juli 2021 - 1:38pm

Recorded on: 22 June 2021

Duration: 00:59:53

A talk by Professor Vili Lehdonvirta on 16 June 2021 to the Digital Futures at Work Research Centre: ‘How does labour market digitalisation affect social mobility? Evidence from a European survey of online platform workers’. Part of the Digit Debates series of talks.

Labor Markets in the 21st Century

OII - Videos - 22 juli 2021 - 1:35pm

Recorded on: 30 June 2021

Duration: 00:52:34

For the very last interview in this series we are joined by David Autor (MIT), Vili Lehdonvirta (University of Oxford), Pascual Restrepo (Boston University), and Maria Savona (University of Sussex) to discuss labour markets in the 21st century, focusing on creating more shared prosperity. How have disruptive technologies such as AI and robotics been affecting labour markets in the last decades, especially in relation to automation? What changes and policies are needed for disruptive technologies, the increasingly digital labour market, and innovation to create more shared prosperity? How does this relate to worker voice, labour unions, the gig economy, and the focus of further research?

Discover The Grammar of Ornament, One of the Great Color Books & Design Masterpieces of the 19th Century

Open Culture - 22 juli 2021 - 1:00pm

In the mid-17th century, young Englishmen of means began to mark their coming of age with a “Grand Tour” across the Continent and even beyond. This allowed them to take in the elements of their civilizational heritage first-hand, especially the artifacts of classical antiquity and the Renaissance. After completing his architectural studies, a Londoner named Owen Jones embarked upon his own Grand Tour in 1832, rather late in the history of the tradition, but ideal timing for the research that inspired the project that would become his legacy.

According to the Victoria and Albert Museum, Jones visited “Italy, Greece, Egypt and Turkey before arriving in Granada, in Spain to carry out studies of the Alhambra Palace that were to cement his reputation.”

He and French architect Jules Goury, “the first to study the Alhambra as a masterpiece of Islamic design,” produced “hundreds of drawings and plaster casts” of the historical, cultural, and aesthetic palimpsest of a building complex. The fruit of their labors was the book Plans, Elevations, Sections and Details of the Alhambra, “one of the most influential publications on Islamic architecture of all time.”

Published in the 1840s, the book pushed the printing technologies of the day to their limits. In search of a way to do justice to “the intricate and brightly colored decoration of the Alhambra Palace,” Jones had to put in more work researching “the then new technique of chromolithography — a method of producing multi-color prints using chemicals.” In the following decade, he would make even more ambitious use of chromolithography — and draw from a much wider swath of world culture — to create his printed magnum opus, The Grammar of Ornament.

With this book, Jones “set out to reacquaint his colleagues with the underlying principles that made art beautiful,” write Metropolitan Museum of Art curator Femke Speelberg and librarian Robyn Fleming. “Instead of writing an academic treatise on the subject, he chose to assemble a book of one hundred plates illustrating objects and patterns from around the world and across time, from which these principles could be distilled.” To accomplish this he drew on his own travel experiences as well as resources closer at hand, including “the museological and private collections that were available to him in England, and the objects that had been on display during the Universal Exhibitions held in London in 1851 and 1855.”

The Grammar of Ornament was published in 1856, emerging into a Britain “dominated by historical revivals such as Neoclassicism and the Gothic Revival,” says the V&A. “These design movements were riddled with religious and social connotations. Instead, Owen Jones sought a modern style with none of this cultural baggage. Setting out to identify the common principles behind the best examples of historical ornament, he formulated a design language that was suitable for the modern world, one which could be applied equally to wallpapers, textiles, furniture, metalwork and interiors.”

Indeed, the patterns so lavishly reproduced in the book soon became trends in real-world design. They weren’t always employed with the intellectual understanding Jones sought to instill, but since The Grammar of Ornament has never gone out of print (and can even be downloaded free from the Internet Archive), his principles remain available for all to learn — and his painstakingly artistic printing work remains available for all to admire — even in the corners of the world that lay beyond his imagination.

You can purchase a complete and unabridged color edition of The Grammar of Ornament online.

Related Content:

The Complex Geometry of Islamic Art & Design: A Short Introduction

Explore the Beautiful Pages of the 1902 Japanese Design Magazine Shin-Bijutsukai: European Modernism Meets Traditional Japanese Design

A Beautiful 1897 Illustrated Book Shows How Flowers Become Art Nouveau Designs

The Bauhaus Bookshelf: Download Original Bauhaus Books, Journals, Manifestos & Ads That Still Inspire Designers Worldwide

Every Page of Depero Futurista, the 1927 Futurist Masterpiece of Graphic Design & Bookmaking, Is Now Online

Based in Seoul, Colin Marshall writes and broadcasts on cities, language, and culture. His projects include the Substack newsletter Books on Cities, the book The Stateless City: a Walk through 21st-Century Los Angeles and the video series The City in Cinema. Follow him on Twitter at @colinmarshall or on Facebook.

Discover The Grammar of Ornament, One of the Great Color Books & Design Masterpieces of the 19th Century is a post from: Open Culture. Follow us on Facebook and Twitter, or get our Daily Email. And don't miss our big collections of Free Online Courses, Free Online Movies, Free eBooksFree Audio Books, Free Foreign Language Lessons, and MOOCs.

Situatie pensioenfondsen verbetert wederom

Binnenllands Bestuur - 22 juli 2021 - 11:41am
De situatie van de pensioenfondsen is in het tweede kwartaal weer verbeterd. Ambtenarenpensioenfonds ABP meldt dat de kans op pensioenverlaging klein is. Indexatie is echter nog ver weg. De grootste risico's zijn volgens het fonds een heropleving van de …

Arnhem verbreekt stedenband met Wuhan om Oeigoeren

Binnenllands Bestuur - 22 juli 2021 - 11:41am
Arnhem verbreekt met onmiddellijke ingang de stedenband met Wuhan in China vanwege de behandeling van Oeigoeren in dat land. Dat heeft een meerderheid van de gemeenteraad besloten, tegen het advies van burgemeester en wethouders in.

Rechtbank staat 'X' als geslachtsaanduiding toe

Binnenllands Bestuur - 22 juli 2021 - 11:41am
Het geslacht van iemand die zich man noch vrouw voelt, mag van de rechtbank in Amsterdam officieel als 'X' op de geboorteakte worden gezet. De rechtbank heeft een non-binair persoon gelijk gegeven die de geboorteakte met terugwerkende kracht wilde laten …

Bijstandsontvangers Den Haag mogen meer giften krijgen

Binnenllands Bestuur - 22 juli 2021 - 11:41am
De gemeente Den Haag heeft het giftenbeleid voor mensen in de bijstand vastgelegd en verruimd. Bijstandsgerechtigden die gehuwd zijn of samenwonen mogen nu 1700 euro per jaar krijgen zonder gekort te worden op hun bijstand. Voor alleenstaanden is dat …

When David Bowie Played Andy Warhol in Julian Schnabel’s Film, Basquiat

Open Culture - 22 juli 2021 - 10:06am

Many actors have played Andy Warhol over the years, but not as many as you might think. Crispin Glover played him in The Doors, Jared Harris played him in I Shot Andy Warhol, Guy Pearce played him in Factory Girl, and Bill Hader played him in Men in Black III, but with a twist: he is actually an agent who is so bad as his cover role as an artist, he’s “painting soup cans and bananas, for Christ sakes!” On television John Cameron Mitchell has acted the Warhol role in Vinyl, and Evan Peters briefly portrayed him in American Horror Story: Cult.

But you might suspect our favorite Warhol would be the one acted by David Bowie in Julian Schnabel’s 1996 Basquiat, the biopic of the Black street artist who was taken into the art world fold by Warhol, and wound up collaborating with him in last works by both artists. Jeffrey Wright plays Basquiat in one of his earliest roles.

Now, you might watch this scene from Basquiat above (and another below) and say, well, that’s just mostly Bowie. But I would say, yes, that’s kind of the point. Andy Warhol is an enigmatic figure, a legend to many, a man who hid behind a constructed persona; David Bowie is too. When one plays the other, a weird sort of magic happens. Fame leaks into fame. Many actors might do better with the mannerisms or the voice, but the charisma…that is all Bowie. After singing about the painter back in 1972, Bowie finally collapsed their visions together in the art of film, where reality and fantasy meet and meld.

Around this time in the mid 1990s, Bowie was very much a part of the New York/London art scene. He was on the editorial board of Modern Painters magazine and interviewed Basquiat director (and artist) Julian Schnabel, Tracey Emin, Damien Hirst, and Balthus. A conceptual artist-slash-serial killer became one of the main characters of his overlooked 1995 Eno collaboration Outside. He was both a collector and an artist, which we’ve focused on before. And he was thinking about the new world opening up because of the internet. Bowie’s artist brain saw the possibilities and the dangers, and also the raw capitalist potential. He offered shares in himself as an IPO in 1997 and released a single as Tao Jones Index, three puns in one. Bowie never predicted the idiocy of the NFT, but he certainly would have laughed wryly at it.

In this Charlie Rose interview to promote Basquiat, Bowie and Schnabel discuss the role of Warhol, the role of art, and the reality of the art world.

“It was more of an impersonation, really,” says Bowie about his Warhol. “That’s how I approach anything.” Of note, however, is how quickly Bowie moves away from discussing himself or the film to talk about larger issues of art and commerce. Bowie does admit that he and Schnabel disagree on a lot of things, and you can see it in their body language. But there’s also a huge respect. It’s a fascinating interview, go watch the whole thing.

Bonus: Below watch Bowie meeting Warhol back during the day…

Related Content:

96 Drawings of David Bowie by the “World’s Best Comic Artists”: Michel Gondry, Kate Beaton & More

The Odd Couple: Jean-Michel Basquiat and Andy Warhol, 1986

When David Bowie Launched His Own Internet Service Provider: The Rise and Fall of BowieNet (1998)

Take a Close Look at Basquiat’s Revolutionary Art in a New 500-Page, 14-Pound, Large Format Book by Taschen

Ted Mills is a freelance writer on the arts who currently hosts the Notes from the Shed podcast and is the producer of KCRW’s Curious Coast. You can also follow him on Twitter at @tedmills, and/or watch his films here.

When David Bowie Played Andy Warhol in Julian Schnabel’s Film, Basquiat is a post from: Open Culture. Follow us on Facebook and Twitter, or get our Daily Email. And don't miss our big collections of Free Online Courses, Free Online Movies, Free eBooksFree Audio Books, Free Foreign Language Lessons, and MOOCs.

Praxis-Workshop zu Urheberrecht und offenen Bildungsmaterialien: Vier Module im Angebot

iRights.info - 22 juli 2021 - 9:08am

Das iRights.Lab bietet einen vierteiligen Praxis-Workshop zu den Themen Urheberrecht und offene Bildungsmaterialien an. Der Workshop ist Teil der iRights.Lab Academy, einem neuen Angebot mit verschiedenen Kursen zu digitalem Lernen und Arbeiten.

Der Workshop „Urheberrecht im Internet“ ist darauf ausgelegt, praxisrelevantes Wissen zu vermitteln und richtet sich vorrangig an Akteur*innen aus dem Bildungs- und Wissenschaftskontext. Sowohl Lai*innen wie auch Fortgeschrittene und Profis können daran teilnehmen und sich entsprechend ihres Wissensstands und ihrer Interessen weiterbilden.

In vier Modulen erläutern die beiden Referenten Henry Steinhau und Tom Hirche die Grundlagen des Urheberrechts, führen in die Nutzung von Creative-Commons-Lizenzen und Open Educational Resources (OER) ein und geben vertiefte Hilfestellung bei der Lizenzierung und Nutzung offener Inhalte. Neben den rechtlichen Aspekten lernen die Teilnehmenden aber auch, wie sie mit digitalen Bildungsmedien, etwa in den sozialen Medien, umgehen und wie sie offene Bildungsmaterialien (OER) finden, nutzen und erstellen können.

Henry Steinhau ist ehemaliger Redakteur bei iRights.info. Er ist Experte für OER und offene Lizenzen sowie vielfach erprobt in praxisnahen Workshops. Tom Hirche ist Rechtswissenschaftler und arbeitet unter anderem zu Gemeinfreiheit im Urheberrecht. Beide arbeiten beim iRights.Lab im Bereich „Forschung & Projekte“.

Weiterführende Informationen zum Kurs „Urheberrecht im Internet“ sowie zu den beiden Referenten finden sich auf der Webseite der iRights.Lab Academy.

iRights.Lab Academy bietet weitere Workshops an

Der Kurs zum Urheberrecht ist Teil eines neuen Training-Angebots, der iRights.Lab Academy. Diese möchte Organisationen und ihre Mitarbeiter*innen mit verschiedenen Angeboten „fit und kompetent für die digitale Zukunft machen“.

So gibt es Kurse zu Diskriminierung und Algorithmen, zum digitalen Wandel der Öffentlichkeit, Daten-Management oder innovativer Verwaltung. Zudem steht ein sogenanntes „Starter-Kit“ für eine erfolgreiche Social-Media-Kommunikation zur Auswahl.

Interessierte können auch eigene Vorschläge für Workshops einreichen, sofern sie sich besondere Themen zur Vertiefung und Weiterbildung durch die iRights.Lab Academy wünschen.

Weitere Informationen, unter anderem zu Anmeldung und Durchführung der Kurse, sind auf den Webseiten der iRights.Lab Academy aufgeführt. Dort finden sich auch Kontaktmöglichkeiten per Mail und Telefon.

Das iRights.Lab ist ein unabhängiger Think Tank, der sich mit Fragen um Veränderungen in der digitalen Welt befasst und dafür Strategien und praktische Lösungen entwickelt, unter anderem für öffentliche Einrichtungen, Stiftungen, Unternehmen, Wissenschaft und Politik.

The post Praxis-Workshop zu Urheberrecht und offenen Bildungsmaterialien: Vier Module im Angebot appeared first on iRights.info - Kreativität und Urheberrecht in der digitalen Welt.

What’s the Role of a Director in Constructing Comedy? Pretty Much Pop: A Culture Podcast #100

Open Culture - 22 juli 2021 - 9:01am

https://podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/traffic.libsyn.com/secure/partiallyexaminedlife/PMP_100_6-24-21.mp3

What makes for a good comedy film or show? Funny people reading (or improvising) funny lines is not enough; an good director needs to capture (or recreate in the editing room) comic timing, construct shots so that the humor comes through and coach the actors to make sure that the tone of the work is consistent.

Your Pretty Much Pop hosts Mark Linsenmayer, Erica Spyres, and Brian Hirt are joined by Heather Fink to discuss the role of the director in making a comedy (or anything else) actually good. Heather has directed for TV, film, and commercials and spent a lot of time doing sound (a boom operator or sound utility) for productions like Saturday Night Live, Get Out, The Morning Show, and Marvel’s Daredevil.

We talk about maintaining comedy through the tedious process of filming, putting actors through sex scenes and other hardships, not telling them how to say their lines, comedians in dramas, directing improv/prank shows, and more. We touch on include Bad Trip, Barry, and Ted Lasso, and more.

Watch some of Heather’s work:

  • Alleged, a short about dramatizing accusations against Steven Segal
  • Inside You, a film she wrote, directed, and (reluctantly) starred in
  • The Focus Group, a short Heather directed written by and starring Sara Benincasa

We used some articles to bring various directors and techniques to mind:

Hear more of this podcast at prettymuchpop.com. This episode includes bonus discussion that you can access by supporting the podcast at patreon.com/prettymuchpop. This podcast is part of the Partially Examined Life podcast network.

Pretty Much Pop: A Culture Podcast is the first podcast curated by Open Culture. Browse all Pretty Much Pop posts.

What’s the Role of a Director in Constructing Comedy? Pretty Much Pop: A Culture Podcast #100 is a post from: Open Culture. Follow us on Facebook and Twitter, or get our Daily Email. And don't miss our big collections of Free Online Courses, Free Online Movies, Free eBooksFree Audio Books, Free Foreign Language Lessons, and MOOCs.

Een zomerserie over ‘taalsmeedsels’, bewust gecreëerde woorden: blending, portmanteau, samentrekking (4)

Nomeis (Siemon Reker) - 22 juli 2021 - 8:40am
Orde in de keet – althans een poging daartoe. In veel blending-gevallen gaat het om stukjes van twee woorden die benut worden, soms zijn het er drie (en desnoods meer zoals Orindek toonde). Om wat abstract naar het resultaat van … Lees verder →

Nee, er is geen officiële bewaartermijn voor beveiligingscamerabeelden

IusMentis - 22 juli 2021 - 8:12am

De Nederlandse politie heeft bijna 280.000 camera’s opgenomen in de Camera In Beeld-database. Dat meldde Tweakers onlangs. De meeste zijn van bedrijven, zo’n 15% is van particulieren. De database is handig als start voor opsporing: je weet precies waar je met je vordering afgifte camerabeelden moet zijn als agent (er is geen live toegang op afstand natuurlijk). En dan het ergerlijke stukje: “Publieke camerabeelden worden gemiddeld langer bewaard dan wettelijk toegestaan.” Dit is niet waar en ik wou dat men ophield dit te zeggen.

De motivatie is dan dat zowel politie als Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens ergens mompelen dat 28 dagen de maximale bewaartermijn is: Het valt op dat de bewaartijd van beelden van de publieke camera’s langer is dan die van particuliere camera’s en mogelijk zelfs de wet overtreedt. Particulieren en bedrijven bewaren camerabeelden gemiddeld 21 dagen. Bij beelden van de overheid gaat het om 38 dagen. Dat is langer dan toegestaan. De politie verwijst zelf naar zijn eigen regels, waarin staat dat camerabeelden maximaal 28 dagen mogen worden bewaard. Ook de Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens noemt een maximale bewaartermijn van vier weken voor camerabeelden ‘van de politie’. Alleen, volgens mij hebben politie en AP het over bewaartermijnen van overheids-camera’s, zoals die een gemeente op zou hangen voor toezicht in de openbare ruimte. In deze database zitten vooral particuliere camera’s (van burgers, zowel bedrijven als personen dus) en dat is juridisch iets heel anders. Die particulieren moeten zich aan de AVG houden, althans als de camera ook de openbare weg filmt. En in de AVG staat géén 28 dagen, daar staat alleen “niet langer dan nodig”.

Oftewel: het hele punt is dat wie een camera ophangt die meer dan eigen terrein filmt, zélf moet gaan bedenken hoe lang zhij de beelden bewaart. Dat moet gemotiveerd en gedocumenteerd (op zijn minst in je privacyverklaring). Er is geen vuistregel of basistermijn.

Heel, heel lang geleden was er een Wet bescherming persoonsgegevens. Die vermeldde ergens dat camerabeelden maximaal 28 dagen bewaard mochten worden. Dat was alleen in de context van de registratieplicht, in die tijd moest je je camera aanmelden bij de AP anders mocht deze er niet hangen. Maar wie de beelden binnen 28 dagen wiste, hoefte de camera niet te melden. Om mij nog steeds volstrekt onverklaarbare redenen zijn hele hordes mensen dit vrijstellingsbesluit gaan lezen als een toestemming om beelden 28 dagen te bewaren. En deze waanzinnige mythe leeft nog steeds door, ik zie ook in publicaties van overigens respectabele juristen anno 2021 doodserieus nog dat vrijstellingsbesluit als bron genoemd voor een bewaartermijn.

Het enige relevante juridische document is deze publicatie van de European Data Protection Board, de samenwerkende toezichthouders. Deze werkt het AVG-kader voor cameratoezicht nader uit, en vermeldt op pagina 28: Taking into consideration the principles of Article 5 (1) (c) and (e) GDPR, namely data minimization and storage limitation, the personal data should in most cases (e.g. for the purpose of detecting vandalism) be erased, ideally automatically, after a few days. The longer the storage period set (especially when beyond 72 hours), the more argumentation for the legitimacy of the purpose and the necessity of storage has to be provided. If the controller uses video surveillance not only for monitoring its premises but also intends to store the data, the controller must assure that the storage is actually necessary in order to achieve the purpose. If so, the storage period needs to be clearly defined and individually set for each particular purpose. De kern is dus: je beelden moeten zo snel mogelijk weg, en het liefst automatisch. En dat “zo snel mogelijk” druk je eerder uit in uren dan in dagen. Als jij iets anders wil, leg maar uit waarom jij in jouw situatie met die beelden voor jouw doeleinden meer nodig hebt. En dan willen we geen dooddoeners horen dat security-randvoorwaarden dit vereisen, dat je ISO auditor in het model 28 dagen had staan (ik citeer een vraagsteller) of dat je wellicht na enkele weken oude beelden wil terugkijken om incidenten te correleren.

Oké, dat was even erg cynisch allemaal. Laat ik het eens positief doen. Hier zijn een aantal voorbeelden van motivaties voor bewaartermijnen, met het verzoek aan jullie om aanvullende tekstvoorstellen te doen!

  • Bij dit woonhuis gebruiken wij camera’s om huis, erf en bewoners te beschermen en (pogingen tot) diefstal, braak en dergelijke vast te leggen. Wij kunnen dan aangifte doen of via de verzekeraar claims indienen. De beelden bewaren wij 72 uur omdat we niet meteen alles zullen opmerken. Periodes van vakantie rekenen we hierin niet mee.
  • Onze winkel is met camera’s beveiligd en we filmen ook de winkelruit in verband met ramkraken en inbraken. De beelden worden aan het einde van elke werkdag vernietigd.
  • Op deze camperstalling wordt met cameratoezicht gewaakt over de geplaatste caravans en campers. Omdat het terrein niet dagelijks door mensen gecontroleerd wordt, worden camerabeelden bewaard tot het einde van de betreffende huurperiode. Camerabeelden waar ook de openbare weg in beeld is, worden wekelijks uitgekeken en vernietigd tenzij incidenten zichtbaar zijn.
In het bijzonder ben ik op zoek naar een voorbeeld van een ‘gewoon’ bedrijf dat camerabeelden 28 dagen mag bewaren. Omdat je normaliter incidenten sneller opmerkt dan dat (de bekraste auto, de inbraak, de vechtpartij bij de personeelsingang) zie ik het niet. De angst voor een stakeout door georganiseerde criminelen die dan eens in de week komt posten om de geldloper te bespringen zodra ze het patroon door hebben voelt een vrij specifiek risico?

Arnoud

 

Het bericht Nee, er is geen officiële bewaartermijn voor beveiligingscamerabeelden verscheen eerst op Ius Mentis.

Onvoorwaardelijk 'leergeld' voor Eindhovense jongeren

Binnenllands Bestuur - 22 juli 2021 - 6:41am
De gemeente Eindhoven investeert ruim 700.000 euro in een innovatieve aanpak van dak- en thuisloosheid onder jongeren. Zo'n dertig jongeren in een kwetsbare situatie krijgen binnenkort een jaar lang een uitkering van 1.050 euro per maand zonder de …

Fusiestrijd: minister en Ombudsman te hulp geroepen

Binnenllands Bestuur - 22 juli 2021 - 6:41am
Minister Ollongren van Binnenlandse Zaken en de Nationale Ombudsman Reinier van Zutphen worden dringend verzocht beiden een onafhankelijk integriteitsonderzoek in te stellen naar de gevolgde herindelingsprocedure Barneveld en Scherpenzeel. Het proces …

The actual left in America has always supported robust civil liberties...

Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog - 21 juli 2021 - 8:25pm
...unlike the New Infantilist left in the universities, on social media today, and even in some of the leftist media. This piece is a useful reminder; an excerpt: The founders of Dissent were fiercely anticommunist, yet you’ll find them repeatedly,... Brian Leiter

Pagina's

Abonneren op Informatiebeheer  aggregator - Van dingen die voorbijkomen